1945-46 - Eppy Barnes, Colgate University (NY)
1947 - Clint Evans, University of California-Berkeley
1948 - Joe Bedenk, Penn State University
1949 - Arthur Mansfield, University of Wisconsin
1950 - J.F. McKale, University of Arizona
1951 - Art Reichle, UCLA
1952 - Paul Amen, U.S. Military Academy (NY)
1953 - Otto Vogel, University of Iowa
1954 - John Kobs, Michigan State University
1955 - Ralph Coleman, Oregon State University
1956 - Ethan Allen, Yale University (CT)
1957 - J.A. “Ike” Tomlinson, Arkansas State University
1958 - L.C. “Cap” Timm, Iowa State University
1959 - Rod Dedeaux, University of Southern California
1960 - J. Orlean Christian, University of Connecticut
1961 - Walter Rabb, University of North Carolina
1962 - Marty Karow, Ohio State University
1963 - Bud Daniel, University of Wyoming
1964 - Jim Whatley, University of Georgia
1965 - Archie Allen, Springfield College (MA)
1966 - John “Hi” Simmons, University of Missouri
1967 - William “Dutch” Fehring, Stanford University (CA)
1968 - Danny Litwhiler, Michigan State University
1969 - Jack Kaiser, St. John’s University (NY)
1970 - Dick Siebert, University of Minnesota
1971 - Frank Sancet, University of Arizona
1972 - Tom Chandler, Texas A&M University
1973 - John Winkin, University of Maine
1974 - Dr. William Arce, Claremont-Mudd College (CA)
1975 - Ron Fraser, University of Miami (FL)
1976 - Harold Kraft, University of North Dakota
1977 - Glen Tuckett, Brigham Young University (UT)
1978 - Elmer Kosub, St. Mary’s University (TX)
1979 - Matt Bolger, Rutgers University (NJ)
1980 - Jack Stallings, Georgia Southern University
1981 - Bobo Brayton, Washington State University
1982 - Dave Keilitz, Central Michigan University
1983 - John “Tinker” Connelly, Northeastern University (MA)
1984 - Tom Petroff, University of Northern Colorado
1985 - Ron Oestrike, Eastern Michigan University
1986 - Ron Polk, Mississippi State University
1987 - Bob Bennett, Fresno State University (CA)
1988 - Bob Hannah, University of Delaware
1989 - Duane Banks, University of Iowa
1990 - Charlie Greene, Miami-Dade South Community College (FL)
1991 - Gene McArtor, University of Missouri
1992 - Jim Dimick, St. Olaf College (MN)
1993 - Jerry Kindall, University of Arizona
1994 - Mark Johnson, Texas A&M University
1995 - Dr. Carroll Land, Point Loma Nazarene University (CA)
1996 - Chuck Anderson, Florida Southern College
1997 - Bob Warn, Indiana State University
1998 - Gary Pullins, Brigham Young University (UT)
1999 - Ed Flaherty, University of Southern Maine
2000 - Keith Madison, University of Kentucky
2001 - Sonny Pittaro, Rider University (NJ)
2002 - Tom O'Connell, Burlington Catholic Central High School (WI)
2003 - David Altopp, Lee University (TN)
2004 - Danny Hall, Georgia Tech
2005 - Irish O'Reilly, Lewis University (IL)
2006 - Bill Holowaty, Eastern Connecticut State University
2007 - Kent Shelley, Johnson County Community College (KS)
2008 - Steve Smith, Baylor University (TX)
2009 - Pat McMahon, University of Florida
2010 - Joe Roberts, Armstrong Atlantic State University (GA)
2011 - Tim Mead, Walsh University (OH)
2012 - John Schaly, Ashland University (OH)
2013 - Tim Corbin, Vanderbilt University (TN)
2014 - Scott Berry, Mayville State University (ND)
2015 - Ed Blankmeyer, St. John’s University (NY)
2016 - John Casey, Tufts University (MA)
2017 - Jeff Messer, Slippery Rock University (PA)
2018 - Rich Maloney, Ball State University (IN)
2019 - John Kolasinski, Siena Heights University (MI)
2020 - Stu Fritz, Hope College (MI)
2021 - Dan McDonnell, University of Louisville (KY)
2022 - Rick Hitt, South Florida State College